Picture
SkateBoarder
Owens, J. ed. (2013). Skateboarder Magazine. San Clemente, CA: Source Interlink Media.


Plot Summary
The first several pages are advertisements for shoe companies such as Volcom and Vans that feature well-known skateboarders.  The Departments page contains topics found in all issues an contain Merchandise (T-shirts and more), R.I.P (Skaters who have passed away), as well as And Another Thing, Skate Anatomy, Memory Screened, Lost & Found, which are short single-page articles or soundbites from well-known skaters.  There are also interviews with skaters, and stories about general skating and skater experiences.  The magazine has a multitude of advertisements for shoes, skateboards, and clothing.  The majority of photographs appear to be of skateboarders doing different tricks.  Tricks include skating on ramps, stairs, jumps, twists.  All have different names like back tail, kickflip, roof ollie, (and my favorite name) switch backside flip nose grind.  Many of the photographs in the April issue were of a trip to Barcelona and include short vignettes of the skaters and how and where they did the tricks.  It seems that each issues tries to showcase a particular skater in a different location, and how their skateboarding works with the locale.  A fairly common topic appears to be what skaters plan to do after.  Skating is mostly for young adults, and one they begin getting married and having families, skateboarding is not as feasible a career. 

Critical Evaluation
Unless one is well-versed in the professional skateboarding world, SkateBoarder will hold little appeal.  There is an entire skateboarding lingo one must know in order to understand what some of the articles are talking about.  Photographs also name the various moves, which will mean nothing to the layperson.  The multitude of advertisements for shoes is incredible.  Some feature familiar shoe brands, while others likely cater to the skateboarding population.  However, a fashion magazine is similar, with many ads, and fewer feature articles.  SkateBoarder's articles are typically rather short.  Several pages are devoted to professional skateboarders and just a sentence of two highlighting some interview that much have been conducted.  Most of the articles and ads feature men, which fits with their general demographic of young adult males.  The interviews with skaters contain some expletives.  When the magazine uses a soundbite that contains an inappropriate word, asterisks are used instead of the offending word.  Despite the asterisks, the word is still easily determined.  In the body of the article, though, the entire word is printed.  There may be a font size rule for expletives.  One of the last sections is for recently deceased skateboarders, which is a nice way to remember those influential in the sport. 

Reader’s Annotation
All you ever wanted to know about skateboarding, professional skaters, and the best products out there.

About the Author
N/A

Genre
Young Adult Periodical/Sports

Curriculum Ties
N/A

Booktalking
Ever wondered what a switch backside flip nose grind looked like?

Reading Level/Interest Level
RL: 7th grade
IL: 9th grade and up

Challenge Issues
Possible challenge issues include explicit language

In my defense file, I would include the following:
1) Library Mission Statement
2) Library Selection Policy approved by any or all of the following individuals—principal, school board, district librarian OR library manager, city council, mayor.
3) Library Bill of Rights adapted from CSLA Bill of Rights, AASL Bill of Rights and/or ALA Bill of Rights
4) Reviews, both positive and critical, from respected sources such as School Library Journal, VOYA, Booklist
5) Rationale for magazine inclusion for titles anticipated to be controversial, frequently challenged, or created when a magazine is challenged including: summary, audience, purpose, controversial issues and how they are handled
6) How the magazine fits within Common Core Standards or State Standards
7) Reconsideration form for challenger to complete—include a section asking which part was of particular concern, if the entire magazine was read, and what other similar titles are suggested instead
8) Student reviews from those who have read the magazine and either enjoyed or disliked the magazine and why.

Why Included
Skateboarding is a popular activity and sport for young adults.  It is important to encourage their interests.

Others in the Series
New issues bimonthly

References
http://www.skateboardermag.com/magazine/

 
Picture
Seventeen
Shoket, A. Ed. (2013). Seventeen. New York: CondeNast.

Plot Summary 
First published in 1944, Seventeen is nearing 70 years of continuous publication -quite a feat in the magazine publishing world. Each issue features a young female celebrity on the cover and a brief article or interview on the inside. The celebrity offers practical advice with little insight on dating, be friends first, and bullying, don’t be a bystander. The table of contents is found several pages in and lists 16 Beauty, Fashion, or Celeb articles and 9 Health, Love and Life features. The models used in the beauty and fashion spreads are multiethnic. The magazine can not be accused of featuring only White teens. The featured products are reasonably priced, $5-$50, and would be affordable for many teen budgets.  Celebrities such as the Kardashians, Selena Gomez, Britney Spears, Pink, and others appear in the advertisements endorsing beauty and fashion products.  The products are often available at Sears, Walmart, and Kohl’s.
The feature articles are extremely short and contain very little information. One entitled, “What He Really Thinks of You” includes five quotes from male teens. Another article, “Is he a Player?’ is a 12 question quiz with three possible solutions.

Critical Evaluation
“I Was Robbed at Gunpoint!” I Rescued My Brothers from a Fire!” Two headlines proclaim on the cover of this glossy teen magazine.  Is this The National Enquirer?
Other headlines advise “825 Ways to Look Pretty,” and “Cute New Fashion for 2013.”  Is this Cosmopolitan?
No, it is Seventeen, a magazine for female adolescents.
The January 2013 and February 2013 issues are filled with advertisements aimed at the teen and preteen female, although the title would indicate an older audience. Overall, the magazine is an advertisement vehicle with a few articles sprinkled in. The advertisements are glossy and in full color and most feature teens or celebrities selling fragrance, fashion and cosmetics. Some mimic the page layouts of the magazine and could easily be mistaken for a short feature or news article.  The magazines features don’t begin until page 84 (out of 117 pages) and are a very brief two paragraphs in length that conclude on the same page. No unwieldy page turning to finish the story. The magazine is a catalog of fashion and beauty products, not a outlet of information relevant to teen women.  Although teens will delight in the flashy full-color illustrations and gossipy nature of the features, adults will find little value.

Reader’s Annotation
Celebrities, gossip, fashion, and boys.  What more could you want in Seventeen?

About the Author
N/A

Genre
Young Adult Periodical

Curriculum Ties
Varies for different issues.
March 2013-  sexual assault

Booktalking
Kendall and Kylie Jenner are just your regular siblings.

Reading Level/Interest Level
RL: 5th grade
IL: 8th grade and up

Challenge Issues
Some of the articles are of a sexual nature or contain sensationalistic topics.

In my defense file, I would include the following:
1) Library Mission Statement
2) Library Selection Policy approved by any or all of the following individuals—principal, school board, district librarian OR library manager, city council, mayor.
3) Library Bill of Rights adapted from CSLA Bill of Rights, AASL Bill of Rights and/or ALA Bill of Rights
4) Reviews, both positive and critical, from respected sources such as School Library Journal, VOYA, Booklist
5) Rationale for magazine inclusion for titles anticipated to be controversial, frequently challenged, or created when a magazine is challenged including: summary, audience, purpose, controversial issues and how they are handled
6) How the magazine fits within Common Core Standards or State Standards
7) Reconsideration form for challenger to complete—include a section asking which part was of particular concern, if the entire magazine was read, and what other similar titles are suggested instead
8) Student reviews from those who have read the magazine and either enjoyed or disliked the magazine and why.

Why Included
Seventeen remains a popular magazine for teen girls, covering an array of different issues pertinent to their lives.  

Others in the Series
New Issues Monthly

References
N/A

 
Picture
TeenVogue
Astley, A. Ed. (2013). TeenVogue. New York: CondeNast.

Plot Summary
TeenVogue is in its tenth anniversary of publication.  Each issue has a similar format.  There are cover stories advertised on the magazine’s cover and specially identified in the table of contents.  Articles are categorized as Fashion, Beauty & Health, and Features.  Each of these has their own special columns, as well as unique stories each issue.  There are many advertisements for clothing and accessory companies found throughout the magazine.  Some of the advertisements are featured by the magazine and include prices. 

The magazine’s first pages are advertisement pages followed by the table of contents and more advertising.  Then, single page articles, interviews, spotlights, bloggers, or notable fashion icons are included.  Again, these are separated by regular advertisements, and those included by TeenVogue with prices.  Within the last thirty pages are more substantial articles.  These articles include interviews with the cover model and a particular issue affecting teens.  I read about AnnaSophia Robb and telling your best friend you have stronger feelings for them, as well as Chloe Grace Moretz and bringing awareness to bullying and sexual harassment. 

Critical Evaluation
I found the magazine to be rather dull.  I read February and March 2013 and both had an over abundance of advertisements.  Many are single or double-spread pages purchased by a fashion company.  The feature articles near the back were interesting, but are nearly hidden and overwhelmed by all the fashion and advertising.  Often, it seemed as if the second part of an article was missing because they were so short. 

Many of the clothing and accessories are also rather expensive for most teenagers.  Items were frequently over $100, an extravagance for young adults.  Chloe Grace Moretz is a model for Aeropostale, one of the more affordable teenage clothing chains, and wore clothing that could be purchased for under $40, much more in line with young adults.

TeenVogue also attempts to showcase unique and individual styles, but these tend to be a little over-the-top in their uniqueness.  I am no longer in the core age group TeenVogue is attracting, but I cannot imagine I would have ever been interested in this magazine even ten years ago.

Reader’s Annotation
Fashion, boys, models, new looks, it’s all here in TeenVogue!

About the Author
N/A

Genre
Young Adult Fashion Periodical

Curriculum Ties
Varies for different issues
March 2013- bullying and sexual harassment

Booktalking
New Fashions and unique fashions

Reading Level/Interest Level
RL: 5th grade and up
IL: 8th grade and up

Challenge Issues
N/A
The issues I read had nothing objectionable about them, except perhaps the overabundance of advertisements.

Others in the Series
New Issues Monthly

Why Included
TeenVogue is a popular magazine for teen girls

References
N/A